Pie in the Sky Menu Prices 2026

The same 2 pound weight at Pie in the Sky costs Rs 2,265 for a Tri Milk Cake and Rs 3,855 for a N.Y Style Cheesecake. I checked the bakery menu line by line, and that Rs 1,590 gap for the same weight is the single most useful number in this article. It tells you that flavour, not size, decides what you pay here.

I could not load the brand’s own menu page today, so every price below comes from the price list on fastfoodmenu.pk, checked by me on 30 October 2026. That list is the actual source used for this article. Prices may vary by branch, and the tracker does not say whether its prices include GST, so confirm the final bill at the counter before you pay.

[OWNER NOTE add own photo or receipt from a Pie in the Sky branch here]

What a celebration cake really costs per pound

Most shoppers compare the headline price and stop there. That is a mistake at this bakery, because a 2.5 pound cake can cost less than a 2 pound cake. Divide by weight and the ranking flips completely. The cheapest celebration cake per pound in the list is the Red Velvet Cake at Rs 934 per pound. The dearest is the N.Y Style Cheesecake at Rs 1,927.50 per pound, more than double the Red Velvet rate.

Item Size Price Price per pound
Red Velvet Cake (New) 2.5 lb Rs 2,335 Rs 934
New Chocolate Fudge Cake 2.5 lb Rs 2,490 Rs 996
Cadbury Chunks Cake 2.5 lb Rs 2,490 Rs 996
Choco-Rose Fantasy 3 lb Rs 3,290 About Rs 1,097
Tri Milk Cake 2 lb Rs 2,265 Rs 1,132.50
Chocolate Heaven Cake 2 lb Rs 2,265 Rs 1,132.50
Lotus Cream Cake 2 lb Rs 2,870 Rs 1,435
N.Y Style Cheesecake 2 lb Rs 3,855 Rs 1,927.50

The lesson is plain. If you want value for a birthday, buy weight first and flavour second. If you want the cheesecake, accept that you are paying a flavour premium of Rs 1,590 over a 2 pound Tri Milk Cake.

If you are buying for one person

Skip the whole cakes entirely. The single serving list is where this bakery is friendliest to a solo buyer. A Chocolate Cupcake costs Rs 110, a Caramel Truffle costs Rs 70, and a Potato Samosa costs Rs 80. My cheapest honest bakery meal from the list is a Potato Samosa at Rs 80 plus a Chicken Patty at Rs 110 plus a Chocolate Cupcake at Rs 110, which totals Rs 300. A Chicken Sandwich at Rs 210 plus a Plain Brownie at Rs 210 totals Rs 420 and feels like a proper lunch.

Item Size Price
Caramel Truffle Per piece Rs 70
Chocolate Truffles Per piece Rs 70
Potato Samosa (S) Each Rs 80
Vegetable Patties Each Rs 90
Chicken Patties Each Rs 110
Chocolate Cupcake (S) Per piece Rs 110
Chicken Sandwich Each Rs 210
Plain Brownie Per piece Rs 210
Chocolate Fudge Pastry Per piece Rs 320
Lotus Dessert In Cup Per piece Rs 420

If you are buying for a small family

For a small family, the 1 pound and 1.5 pound cakes are the sweet spot. A 1 pound Chocolate Cake costs Rs 1,430 and a 1 pound Oreo Mocha Cake costs Rs 1,410. Step up to 1.5 pounds and the Chocolate Fudge Cake costs Rs 1,580, which is only Rs 150 more than the 1 pound Chocolate Cake for half a pound extra. That small step is the best value jump on the whole menu. The Kentucky loaf cakes sit in the same range, with Kentucky Butter Cake at Rs 580 for 1 pound, Kentucky Marble Cake at Rs 670, and Kentucky Fruits Cake at Rs 750.

Item Size Price
Kentucky Butter Cake 1 lb Rs 580
Kentucky Marble Cake 1 lb Rs 670
Kentucky Fruits Cake 1 lb Rs 750
Oreo Mocha Cake (New) 1 lb Rs 1,410
Chocolate Cake 1 lb Rs 1,430
Chocolate Fudge Cake (S) 1.5 lb Rs 1,580
Peach and Orange Cheesecake 1.5 lb Rs 2,210
Mocha Java Cake 2 lb Rs 2,210

If you are buying for a party

For a party, buy the 2.5 pound Red Velvet Cake at Rs 2,335 and stop second guessing. It is the cheapest per pound celebration cake in the list, and it still reads as a proper celebration cake. The 2.5 pound New Chocolate Fudge Cake and Cadbury Chunks Cake both cost Rs 2,490, which is Rs 155 more for the same weight. The 3 pound Choco-Rose Fantasy at Rs 3,290 only makes sense for a larger gathering, since its per pound rate of about Rs 1,097 is higher than the Red Velvet rate.

If you are buying a cake as a gift

Be careful here, because gift listings charge far more than the bakery counter. The tracker lists a 2.5 pound Cadbury Chunks Cake at Rs 2,490, while a third party gift listing was found charging Rs 5,999 for a 2 pound version of the same cake for Karachi delivery. That is more than double the bakery price for a smaller cake. If someone else is ordering for you, ask whether the price quoted is the bakery price or a delivered gift price, because the two are very different numbers.

Two warnings before you order

First, GST treatment is unconfirmed. An older review of the Zamzama cafe reported that menu prices were listed without 13 percent GST and that GST was added at checkout. The current tracker does not say whether its prices include GST. Treat every price here as the listed price and ask at the counter whether GST is included.

Second, mango items are seasonal. The list includes a Fresh Mango Tart at Rs 100 per piece, a Mango Sunshine Cake at Rs 1,830 for 1.5 pounds, and a Mango Lava Cake at Rs 2,450 for 2 pounds. Mango season is over in October, so confirm availability before you plan around a mango cake. The same caution applies to branch stock generally, since prices and availability may vary by branch.

Shelf items and breads worth knowing

The bakery shelf is a separate world from the cake counter, and packaged versions cost more per gram than loose versions of the same item. Loose Cake Rusk costs Rs 455 for 250 gm, which works out to Rs 1,820 per kg, while Packaged Cake Rusk costs Rs 800 for 300 gm, which works out to Rs 2,667 per kg. Treat packaged items as a gift tier, not as the same product at the same price. A Sugar Free Cake Rusk pack costs Rs 723 for 250 gm, which is useful to know if you are buying for someone who avoids sugar.

Item Size Price
Plain Bread Per pack Rs 220
Brown Bread Per pack Rs 230
Multigrain Bread Per pack Rs 340
Cake Rusk 250 gm From Rs 455
Biscuits (Mix) 250 gm Rs 455
Sugar Free Cake Rusk 250 gm Rs 723
Packaged Cake Rusk 300 gm Rs 800

For more bakery prices in Karachi, see my Tehzeeb Bakers menu prices and Layers Bakeshop menu prices. If you are planning a full day out, my best breakfast places in Karachi with prices covers where to eat before the cake run.

Frequently asked questions

Q. How much does a 2 pound Pie in the Sky cake cost in Pakistan

A. A 2 pound cake ranges from Rs 2,265 for a Tri Milk Cake or Chocolate Heaven Cake to Rs 3,855 for a N.Y Style Cheesecake, based on the price list checked on 30 October 2026. Flavour decides the price at the same weight.

Q. What is the cheapest celebration cake per pound at Pie in the Sky

A. The 2.5 pound Red Velvet Cake at Rs 2,335 works out to Rs 934 per pound, which is the cheapest per pound celebration cake in the list. The 2.5 pound New Chocolate Fudge Cake and Cadbury Chunks Cake both cost Rs 2,490, or Rs 996 per pound.

Q. What is the cheapest thing to buy at Pie in the Sky

A. A Caramel Truffle or a Chocolate Truffles piece costs Rs 70, and a Potato Samosa costs Rs 80. A filling solo snack of a Potato Samosa plus a Chicken Patty plus a Chocolate Cupcake totals Rs 300.

Q. Does Pie in the Sky sell savoury items as well as cakes

A. Yes, the savoury list includes Chicken Patties at Rs 110 each, a Chicken Sandwich at Rs 210, a Spicy Hunter Beef Sandwich at Rs 280, and a small Chicken Pizza at Rs 260. These are bakery counter items, not a separate restaurant menu.

Q. Are there sugar free options at Pie in the Sky

A. The list includes a Sugar Free Cake Rusk pack at Rs 723 for 250 gm. No other sugar free cake price was verified in this check, so ask the branch about sugar free cake options before ordering.

Q. Why do gift listings charge so much more than the bakery price

A. Gift listings bundle delivery and gift handling into the price. A gift listing was found charging Rs 5,999 for a 2 pound Cadbury Chunks Cake for Karachi delivery, against a bakery list price of Rs 2,490 for a 2.5 pound version. Always confirm whether a quote is the bakery price or a delivered gift price.

Last verified 30 October 2026. Prices vary by branch and delivery platform, and GST treatment is unconfirmed, so confirm the final price with the branch before ordering.

Leave a Comment